Commonhold Explained: How New Leasehold Ban Changes Property Ownership in England and Wales
The UK government has introduced the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill to ban most new leasehold flats in England and Wales, replacing them with commonhold ownership. While this shift aims to eliminate diminishing leases and give residents greater control over building management, legal experts warn that disputes over maintenance costs and repairs will persist under the new system.
The UK government has published the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, a legislative package designed to ban most new leasehold flats in England and Wales and replace them with a system known as commonhold. The bill represents a significant overhaul of property ownership laws following years of criticism regarding the transparency and fairness of the current leasehold model.
Under the existing leasehold system, which applies to millions of homes across England and Wales, buyers purchase the right to occupy a property for a fixed period, typically 99, 125, or 999 years. The land and the building’s structure remain owned by a separate landlord or freeholder. Leaseholders are required to pay service charges for the maintenance of shared areas, roofs, and building insurance, as well as ground rent.
Critics of the current system have highlighted issues with rising service charges, unaffordable ground rents, and high costs associated with enfranchising, or taking control of, their buildings. The new bill addresses some of these concerns by capping ground rent at £250 per year and making it easier for existing leaseholders to switch to commonhold ownership.
Commonhold offers a different structure of ownership. Under this system, residents hold permanent freehold ownership of their individual flats, eliminating the need to negotiate lease extensions as the property’s term diminishes. A commonhold association, comprising the flat owners in a specific block, jointly owns the communal parts of the building and the land it sits on. This structure provides owners with greater control over repairs and insurance providers, and removes ground rent obligations entirely.
The bill also impacts "share of freehold" arrangements, where leaseholders own their individual property plus a share of the freehold for the entire building. While this model already offers more control over costs and management compared to standard leasehold, it still involves a diminishing lease. The new legislation aims to make commonhold the default for most new flats and homes built in the future.
Despite the potential benefits, legal experts and mortgage advisers caution that commonhold does not eliminate the complexities of managing shared residential buildings. Nouran Moustafa, a mortgage adviser at Roxton Wealth, described the traditional leasehold model as "extraordinary" because it involves buying the right to occupy land rather than owning it outright. He noted that the primary financial concern with leasehold is that it is a diminishing asset; as the remaining term shortens, extending the lease becomes more expensive and can restrict mortgage options.
Moustafa stated that while share of freehold provides "more control," commonhold involves "no lease ticking down towards expiry." However, he warned that commonhold is not a solution to all property management issues. "It isn’t a magical escape from property management costs," he said, emphasizing that owners must still pay for building insurance and coordinate repairs.
Camilla Tunnicliffe, a lawyer in the property team at Farrer & Co, echoed these concerns. She noted that while commonhold removes the landlord and the diminishing leasehold interest, it does not remove the need to manage, maintain, and pay for a shared building. "Owners will still disagree about repairs, expenditure and alterations, and some will fail to pay their share," Tunnicliffe said.
Estella Prince, a partner at Ramsdens Solicitors, added that disputes over maintenance can escalate quickly when neighbors disagree on what work is needed, who should carry it out, or how much should be spent. She described the phasing out of leaseholds and the granting of greater control to flat owners as positive in principle but warned that it would "undoubtedly give rise to a fresh series of threats that come with collective management."
The government’s previous reforms last year sought to make it easier for leaseholders to take control of their building’s management and extend leases. The new bill builds on these efforts by fundamentally altering the default ownership structure for new developments, aiming to address the lack of control and expiring leases that have long plagued the leasehold sector.
S.Schuster--MP